Tuesday 22 June 2010

Country or Self - Which Ranks Higher?

"I told them they could no longer be heroes for our children. They have destroyed the dreams of their countrymen, their friends and supporters – Roselyn Bachelot, French Sports Minister."

The French football team have provided us with unprecedented World Cup entertainment since the day they qualified, but reports of dissension in the camp have been of particular interest as they bring into question the national pride of the French players.

Anelka was reportedly sent back to France after insulting coach Raymond Domanech in the locker room after their loss to Mexico. This was followed by reports that the French team boycotted training the following day and that France team director Jean-Louis Valentin resigned.

Reports. Reports. Reports. Any athlete worth their salt will tell you that what happens in the locker room – stays in the locker room. End of.

As the exchange between Anelka and Domanech appears to be a leak anyway, the scandal is already overhyped. But let’s just say that for arguments sake the French team are justified in their actions – at what stage is it ok for a player to put himself before his country.

I’m guessing that had Adebayor known the impact of the decision to travel via bus instead of plane during the African Cup of Nations, he would have opted to travel by plane. My question is, had he done this, would he have been described as being disloyal to his country?

Unfortunately, we will never know. Even more unfortunately, three people paid for this decision with their lives.

Admittedly, this is an extreme example, but it does bring into question whether or not a player should sacrifice personal pride for national pride.

In my opinion, this particular argument on national pride extends beyond the players to the person that leaked details of the altercation, the French media’s reports of the mutiny, the French Football federation’s handling of the scandal and Domenech’s inability to effectively manage his squad.

2 comments:

  1. I did not even bother to watch the game today because the mere fact that players selected to represent their country - an honour so esteemed - and yet decide that they could not be bothered, did not warrant my attention. I told a co-worker today that France, for the total disrespect they have shown this tournament and all the small nations who work hard and fight to qualify, shedding tears when they try and fail or teams like North Korea who give their all against giants like Brazil and Portugal and leave the field in tears after a drubbing, yet knowing they have done their best - a team like FRANCE should be banned from even qualifying for the next World Cup for their antics on and off the field!!!! It is a slap in the face for every player whose dream from the moment they saw Pele or Maradona or Platini for that matter kick a ball was to be in a World Cup wearing their national colours.

    Just show me the petition to ban the whole bag o' dem, and I will damn well sign it!

    (lol)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I saw this blog post and immediately thought of you as it relates to the topics of your last three posts (incl this one)

    enjoy!
    http://livinginbarbados.blogspot.com/2010/06/what-to-do-with-sorry-bunch-of-overpaid.html

    ReplyDelete